renewalsrenewal-strategyclaims-data

Your Renewal Came In +20%. Now What?

By November 16, 20266 min read

A 20% renewal is far more often a price problem than a usage problem, but you can't tell which one drove yours without your data. And what you can do about it depends on how big you are and how your plan is funded.

Key takeaways

  • Healthcare cost comes down to two U's: utilization and unit cost. From 2019 to 2023, prices rose 17.7% and use rose 1.8%.
  • At 50 or fewer employees, fully insured, your own claims don't set your rate. The carrier's filing, age, plan and geography do.
  • No federal law makes a carrier hand a fully insured group its claims. Texas, Florida, Ohio and Virginia do, at different group sizes.
  • Ask for the rating exhibit in writing, about 90 days before your renewal.
  • Pushing more cost onto employees moves cost. It doesn't cut it.

This fall, a handful of my clients called me about their renewals. Most of them already knew what was coming. We'd had this conversation months ago, with their own data when we could. We knew whether it was unit cost, utilization, or the carrier's trend that was going to drive the number.

Then there's all the other employers who were caught off guard this fourth quarter. This is for them.

Is your renewal a price problem or a usage problem?

Most of the time, it's price. Healthcare cost comes down to the two U's, utilization or unit cost, and one of those two is driving your renewal.

From 2019 to 2023, unit cost drove almost all of the increase. Prices rose 17.7%. Use rose 1.8% over the same five years. That's from the Health Care Cost Institute, whose report opens with one line: prices continue to drive health care spending growth. Use fell in 2022 and 2023, and prices still rose more than 6% a year. And RAND found employers pay hospitals about two and a half times what Medicare pays for the same care.

That doesn't mean it'll look the same every year. There's fair pushback, and it's drugs. Drugs are a use story. The Milliman Medical Index says pharmacy is the fastest-growing cost, and GLP-1s are the driver.

My take: price is driving most of your increase. But drugs, GLP-1s, or one large claimant are a real risk for your health plan. We covered where the premium dollar goes in where your premium goes.

What drove your increase?

That depends on how big you are. The average family premium went up 5% in 2026, according to the KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey. So if yours went up 10%, 15%, or 20%, do you know where the difference came from?

Usually, it's one of four things. The carrier's filing. Everyone got older. One big claim. Or pooling and plan changes.

Which one depends on a line most employers aren't watching: 50 employees.

At 50 or fewer, fully insured, your own claims don't set your rate. Federal rules allow only four rating factors, in one statewide pool. California, Colorado, New York and Vermont set that line at 100. What moves a small group renewal is the carrier's filing, the age of your people, the plans you pick, and where you are. The median small group filing for 2027 asked for 14%. A 14% filing plus a year of birthdays can get you most of the way to 20 with no claims at all.

At 51 or more, you move into most carriers' middle market. Your claims are still pooled, but now they count, blended by credibility. One person can change how your group renews.

Can you see your own claims data?

Often, no. There's no federal law that makes a fully insured carrier hand over its claims data.

Some states do. In Texas, any group gets a claims report within 30 days. In Florida, any group gets loss runs within 15 days. Ohio covers groups with 50 or more full-time employees. Virginia, 100 or more covered people.

Every other Wednesday. Unsubscribe anytime. We may show your company’s logo on our homepage. Privacy

Wherever you are, there's one thing you can ask for: the rating exhibit. In writing, well before your renewal date. You should be able to get it about 90 days out. My prepared clients had theirs months ago. That's the difference between walking in ready and not knowing what to expect.

And if the carrier won't show it to you, that's an answer too. Fully insured is renting. The carrier owns the risk and the data. When you self-fund or level-fund, you own your data. You become the homeowner. You're responsible for the maintenance, but you also get the equity.

What are your options at your size?

There are three doors, and your headcount picks which one you walk through.

Door 1: 50 or fewer. Shop it. Look at fully insured alternatives, level-funded carriers, an ICHRA (now called a CHOICE arrangement, a new name with no rule change), maybe a smaller captive. Level-funded is where most small groups go first. Almost four in ten covered workers at small firms are already in one. The Labor Department treats these plans as self-funded, so know that for compliance. Two things to understand before you sign. You're medically underwritten to get in. And you may see lasers at renewal. If the first year goes bad, you can go back to the community-rated pool. The funding models guide lays out the differences.

Door 2: 50 and up. Shift the plan design, layer navigation on top, and fund the gap with a health reimbursement arrangement. Only the employer puts money in. Find the best-performing facilities at the lowest contracted cost, then the best doctors at those facilities. If your employees choose them, the HRA covers their cost.

Door 3: larger and self-funded. Use your data to go straight at unit cost. Reference-based pricing is the strongest argument here. Know the risk first. If your plan has no network of contracted facilities, federal surprise-billing protections don't cover scheduled care. Emergency care is still protected. We covered how to pick a vendor in reference-based pricing vendor selection.

What shouldn't you do?

Don't hit the easy button. The most common move is pushing more premium, deductibles and copays onto employees. It moves cost. It doesn't cut it. The healthy employees leave first, and the people left in next year's pool are sicker.

Here's what I'd do instead, before you sign:

  1. Get the exhibit. Or your claims report where the law requires it. In writing, about 90 days out.
  2. Split the increase. Is it utilization or unit cost?
  3. Know your line. Your headcount decides whether your claims even matter.
  4. Price the doors. Level-funded, CHOICE, self-funded, captives. Model them for your population and your cash flow.
  5. Go after price. Steer care and control unit cost. Do that and you don't have to keep taking more from your employees every year.

Frequently asked questions

Why did my health insurance renewal go up 20%?

Usually it's one of four things: the carrier's filed rate change, your group getting a year older, one large claim, or pooling and plan changes. At 50 or fewer employees on a fully insured plan, your own claims don't set the rate. At 51 or more, they start to count.

Can a fully insured employer get its claims data?

There's no federal law that requires it. Texas and Florida require a claims report or loss run for any size group, Ohio for groups with 50 or more full-time employees, and Virginia for 100 or more covered people. Anywhere, you can ask for the rating exhibit in writing.

Is level-funded the same as self-funded?

For compliance purposes, yes. The Labor Department treats level-funded arrangements as self-funded. You're medically underwritten to get in, and you may face lasers at renewal.

Should I raise deductibles to offset a big renewal?

It moves cost onto employees without cutting it. The healthy employees leave first, and next year's pool is sicker. Before you sign, see which funding approach fits your company with the free Funding Fit assessment.

Share this article

The math is there. You just need someone to show you.

Bi-weekly analysis across five pillars. Written in financial language for the people who own the budget.

Every other Wednesday. Unsubscribe anytime. We may show your company’s logo on our homepage. Privacy